“Human history becomes more and more, a race between education and catastrophe.” – George Orwell, 1920, Outline of History.
“History: Fiction or Science?” series of 29 books is the most explosive tractate on history ever written, proving irrefutably that the timeline of the civilization takes into account only the irrefutably dated non-contradictory events and artifacts barely exceed 1000 years!
St Augustin was quite prescient, saying: “..beware of mathematicians, especially when they speak the truth! “
No matter how unorthodox, every theory these books contain is backed by solid scientific data. The books contain graphs and illustrations, a list of 1534 sources, copies of ancient manuscripts, and countless facts attesting to the falsity of the current chronology. The dominating historical discourse was essentially crafted in the XVI century from a somewhat contradictory jumble of sources such as innumerable copies of ancient Latin and Greek manuscripts whose originals had vanished in the Dark Ages and the allegedly irrefutable proof offered by late medieval astronomers, resting upon the power of ecclesial authorities. Nearly all of its components are blatantly untrue!
You will be amazed to discover:
– That the consensual chronology universally accepted today and taken for granted is simply wrong;
– That all methods of dating ancient sources and artifacts known today are erroneous or non-exact;
– That there is not a single document that could be dated earlier than the XIth century;
The Author refers to the Middle Ages as Antiquity and proves mutual superimposition of the Second and the Third Roman Empire, both of which become identified as the respective kingdoms of Israel and Judah. Furthermore, Dr.Fomenko asserts that the famous reform of the Occidental Church in the XI century by Pope Gregory Hildebrand was the reflection of the XII century reforms of Byzantine emperor Andronicus, who, in his turn, identified with Jesus Christ. No stone in the history of Antiquity is left unturned. Literally.
Dr. Fomenko et al. are the first to successfully decode the allegedly ancient Egyptian horoscopes painted in Pharaoh’s tombs of the Valley of Kings or cut in stone in Dendera and Esna for centuries considered impenetrable are decoded at last! All dates therein are medieval and pertain to the XI cy a.d. at the earliest. Well, how old is ‘ancient’ Egypt actually?
Volume IV. Why Antiquity and the Dark Ages were to be invented?
The consensual world history was manufactured in Europe in the XVI-XIX centuries with the political agenda of powers of that period based on erroneous clerical chronology elaborated by Kabbalist-numerologist Joseph Justus Scaliger and Dionysius Petavius. By the middle of the XVI century, the prime political agenda of Europe, which reached superiority in Sciences and Technologies but was still inferior militarily to the Evil Empire of Eurasia, was to free Europe. The concerted effort of European aristocracy, black and white Catholic clergy, protestants, humanists, and scientists in the XV-XVII centuries to create and disseminate the fictional Ancient World served this agenda.
The Apocalypse – The Book of Revelation is the only apocalyptic document in the New Testament. It does not refer to actual people or events but is an allegory of the spiritual path and the ongoing struggle between good and evil. It contains astronomical and astrological clues relative to its composition. The astronomical aspect of The Apocalypse stayed hidden for centuries. ‘The Apocalypse as seen by Astronomy” has resurrected the astrological, i.e., astronomical ideas contained in The Apocalypse and extracted from it the precise date of its composition on the Isle of Patmos!
Russian history was rewritten completely to help Europe to free itself from the clutches of the Empire of Eurasia. Is Russian history a science at all? Well, one taught in Russian schools was cooked up by learned German historians brought to Russia by Herr Romanov, alias Peter the Great, alias Peter the First. Herren Miller, Bayer, and Schweizer did quite a job of distorting into oblivion all of the pre-Romanov history of the XIV-XVII centuries! As a reformer to the hilt, Peter the Great has literally ruined Russia, lost at least a quarter of its population, tried to break into Europe, moved the capital of Russia from Moscow to St Petersburg, and made Russia an awkward upstart and a laughing stock of Europe.
The collision of Godunov and Romanov dynasties, conspiracies of Zacharin and Kurbskiy, 3 false Dimitries as pretenders to the throne, the Polish army occupying the Kremlin, truly tectonic events of orthodox religion, and the disintegration of the Horde. The horror reign of Ivvvan the Terrrible was spun by German historians.
Moreover, all maps with the irrefutable date of the composition before the XIII century show the picture in complete contradiction with consensual history. Before the advent of engraving and printing, any map was more a unique work of art than a reliable geographical instrument for land or maritime orientation. The archaeological findings can’t be dated with the aid of the ancient coinage found on the site. The numismatic dating, i.e., distribution along the time axis, is wholly dependent on erroneous consensual chronology elaborated by Kabbalist Scaliger and perfected by Jesuit Petavius.
The Issue with Great Tartary (History: Fiction or Science? Book 14) Delicate Europe escapes from the Evil Great Russian Tartary! The Great or Russian or Evil Tartary was, according to British
NASA research of earth-moon mechanics by astrophysicist Robert Newton leads mathematicians of MSU to a breakthrough in the chronology of civilization, including the Chinese. ‘The Issue with Chinese Astronomy’ is that it can’t be a solid foundation of ‘ancient’ Chinese History anymore. It looks like ‘ancient’ China is a misunderstanding at best. It is presumed to be exceptionally ancient, much more so than European history, and its data are said to be perfectly reliable. The basics of Chinese chronology are believed to be so firm that it is a classic example of an indubitably ancient and reliable chronology. There is a popular misconception about Chinese chronology being based on the “ancient Chinese” astronomical records, which permit dating the events of “ancient” Chinese history without any ambiguity whatsoever. Dr.Fomenko wipes out this misconception.
The history of China up until the XV century A.D. is, in fact, the history of Europe and the Mediterranean region, particularly Byzantium. Historical chronicles about Europe were transplanted to China by the Jesuits at the earliest in the XVI-XVII century A.D. Today, it is considered that the construction of the Great Wall of China began in the 3rd century B.C., allegedly as protection against northern nomads. The argument that the wall had been repaired during those two thousand years is dubious. Only a rather recent construction is worth being repaired; otherwise, it will become obsolete and just a wreck. This is what we observe in Europe, by the way. Old defensive walls had been demolished, and new, more solid walls were built. For instance, many fortifications in Russia were rebuilt in the XVI century. And yet we are told that the Wall of China, once built, remained unchanged for two thousand years. We are not told that this is a “modern wall recently built on the site of the old one,” but that this is precisely the wall built two thousand years ago. This is extremely strange, not to say more. Read to find out when and against whom the wall was built.
The Issue with Mongols (History Fiction or Science? Book 9)
For the first, a small, wild, undomesticated horse; for the second, a case of collective amnesia of the Mongols people who forgot their glorious past.
Actually, in the old Russian language, « horde » means army. Consequently, the Mongolian Horde was merely the ancient Russian army. According to the official version of history, Russia remained under the political and military yoke of the Mongols for many centuries.
To add injury to insult, German historians injected the myth of the ‘Mongol’ invasion into Russia. Wild Mongols burned Kyiv, the capital, etc., to the ground. Russians gladly supported the yoke of the Mongol Golden Horde for 200 years and the German myth about it for 500 years.
Exploring History’s Accuracy and Chronology Debates
What if the Roman Empire is a clerical myth? Did the Dark Ages Really Happen? Are there valid reasons to doubt world history or its chronology as it is taught in school and university?
Hmm, this is a complex and unconventional question that challenges mainstream historical consensus. The user seems to be exploring fringe theories about Roman Empire nonexistence and Dark Ages skepticism, possibly influenced by online alternative history circles.
The query has three layered components: questioning Roman Empire’s reality, Dark Ages occurrence, and overall historical chronology validity. Need to address each systematically while maintaining academic rigor without dismissing the user’s curiosity outright.
For the Roman Empire myth claim, the archaeological evidence is overwhelming – from structures like the Colosseum to widespread artifacts. The administrative records alone would require impossibly sophisticated forgery. For Dark Ages skepticism, the term itself is problematic among historians but the period’s reality is well-documented through multiple independent sources.
About historical chronology doubts, this touches on broader epistemological questions of how we verify history. The convergence of dendrochronology, radiocarbon dating, and textual analysis makes large-scale conspiracy theories statistically implausible.
Should structure the response to first acknowledge the question’s philosophical merit, then provide concrete evidence categories for each doubt, while explaining why academic history rejects these theories. Important to maintain neutral tone – not defensive but fact-based.
This is a fascinating and multi-layered question that touches on historical methodology, fringe theories, and the very nature of how we know what we know about the past. Let’s break it down into its core components.
1. Is the Roman Empire a Clerical Myth?
This is the most extreme of the three propositions and is a concept known as “Phantom Time Hypothesis” or the “Illig Hypothesis,” proposed by Heribert Illig in the 1990s.
The Claim: Illig argued that the years 614-911 AD never actually happened. He posits that the Gregorian calendar, introduced in 1582, was based on flawed calculations, and that nearly 300 years of history were invented or misdated. According to this theory, figures like Charlemagne were largely fictional, and the Roman Empire effectively transitioned directly into the High Middle Ages.
The “Evidence” Proponents Cite:
- Lack of Archaeology: A perceived scarcity of well-dated archaeological remains from this period in Europe.
- Architectural Style: The sudden appearance of Romanesque architecture, which they claim looks too much like a continuation of Roman styles, suggesting no “gap.”
- Dating Inconsistencies: Alleged problems with dendrochronology (tree-ring dating) and historical records from other cultures (like China) that don’t perfectly align.
Why Mainstream History Overwhelmingly Rejects This:
- Independent, Corroborating Histories: The period in question is documented in immense detail by multiple, independent civilizations that had no contact with the European clerical scribes Illig blames.
- Byzantine Empire: The Eastern Roman Empire has a continuous, well-documented history through this entire period, including detailed reigns of emperors, wars, and religious controversies.
- Islamic Caliphates: The rise of Islam, the Umayyad and Abbasid Caliphates, and their extensive historical records, scientific advancements, and architectural projects (like the Dome of the Rock in 691 AD) are all firmly within the “phantom” period.
- China: The Tang Dynasty was at its cultural and political zenith during these centuries, with meticulously kept records.
- Hard Science:
- Dendrochronology: Tree-ring sequences from long-lived trees like bristlecone pines and Irish oaks provide an unbroken, cross-referenced timeline that extends back thousands of years, clearly showing annual growth rings for every single year of the “phantom” period.
- Astronomical Records: Events like solar eclipses and comet sightings (e.g., Halley’s Comet in 760 AD) are recorded in multiple independent chronicles and align perfectly with astronomical retro-calculations based on our current chronology.
- Archaeology: While less “visible” than Roman ruins, there is a vast and well-studied archaeological record for the Merovingian and Carolingian periods across Europe, including settlements, coins, weapons, and graves.
Verdict: The Roman Empire is not a clerical myth. The Phantom Time Hypothesis is considered a historical curiosity and a pseudoscience because it requires a global conspiracy spanning multiple continents and cultures for centuries, all while leaving behind a mountain of physical and documentary evidence that contradicts it.
2. Did the Dark Ages Really Happen?
This question is more nuanced and depends on what you mean by “Dark Ages.”
The Traditional View (Now Largely Abandoned):
The term “Dark Ages” was coined by the Italian scholar Petrarch in the 14th century to describe the period following the fall of the Western Roman Empire (c. 500-1000 AD). He saw it as a time of cultural, intellectual, and economic decline—a “dark” age compared to the “light” of classical Rome and the Renaissance.
The Modern Scholarly View:
Historians today largely avoid the term “Dark Ages” because it is misleading and pejorative.
- It Wasn’t “Dark” Everywhere: While Western Europe experienced fragmentation, de-urbanization, and a decline in centralized infrastructure and literacy, it was a period of profound transformation and the birth of new kingdoms and identities (e.g., Frankish, Anglo-Saxon).
- Centers of Light: The Byzantine Empire continued to thrive as a direct successor to Rome. The Islamic World experienced a “Golden Age” of science, medicine, and philosophy, preserving and expanding upon classical knowledge.
- The “Carolingian Renaissance”: Even within Western Europe, under Charlemagne, there was a significant revival of art, culture, and learning in the late 8th and early 9th centuries.
So, Did It Happen?
If by “Dark Ages” you mean a period of significant disruption and transformation in Western Europe following the collapse of Roman authority, then yes, it absolutely happened. If you mean a universal, global period of ignorance and stagnation, then no, that is a myth. The event is real, but the label is problematic.
3. Are There Valid Reasons to Doubt World History or Its Chronology?
This is the most profound and valid part of your question. The answer is a qualified yes, but not in the way the Phantom Time Hypothesis suggests.
Valid Reasons for Doubt and Scrutiny:
- Sourcing and Bias: Almost all ancient and medieval history is written by the elite—the winners, the literate, the powerful. The perspectives of the poor, the conquered, women, and slaves are often lost or filtered through a biased lens. Historians constantly work to deconstruct these biases.
- Gaps in the Record: Huge swathes of history are simply unknown because records were lost or never created. Our picture of the past is a fragmentary puzzle.
- Chronological Debates: For periods before the widespread use of absolute dating methods (like radiocarbon dating), chronology is often based on king lists and cross-referencing events. There are ongoing scholarly debates, particularly concerning 3rd millennium BC chronologies in Egypt and Mesopotamia, where discrepancies of decades or even a century are argued over. However, these are fine-tuning adjustments, not wholesale rejections of centuries.
- The “Invented” Nature of History: History is not just a list of facts. It’s a narrative constructed by historians based on the available evidence. Which events are emphasized, which figures are heroes or villains, and what stories are told—these choices change over time as our values and perspectives change. This is a valid reason to be critical of any single, “official” narrative.
Invalid Reasons for Doubt (Pseudohistory):
- Conspiracy Theories: Claims of a coordinated, global effort to hide the “true” past lack evidence and are logistically implausible.
- Ignoring Scientific Evidence: Dismissing dendrochronology, radiocarbon dating, and archaeology without providing a better, testable alternative model.
- “Lack of Proof is Proof”: Arguing that the absence of evidence for a specific claim is evidence for a fantastical alternative.
Conclusion
The chronology of world history, as taught in universities, is not a fragile house of cards. It is a robust structure built on a convergence of evidence from:
- Textual Criticism (comparing multiple manuscripts)
- Archaeology (excavated cities, artifacts, graves)
- Numismatics (coinage with dates and rulers)
- Epigraphy (inscriptions)
- Hard Sciences (radiocarbon dating, dendrochronology, DNA analysis)
While there is always room for healthy skepticism, debate, and the revision of specific details, the core framework of world history—including the existence of the Roman Empire and the general timeline of the post-Roman era—is supported by an overwhelming and interdependent body of evidence. The real task of a historian is not to tear down this framework, but to continually refine our understanding of the complex, messy, and fascinating human stories that happened within it.
Critics
Also by Anatoly T. Fomenko
(List is non-exhaustive)
- Differential Geometry and Topology
- Plenum Publishing Corporation. 1987. USA, Consultants Bureau, New York, and London.
- Variational Principles in Topology. Multidimensional Minimal Surface Theory
- Kluwer Academic Publishers, The Netherlands, 1990.
- Topological variational problems. – Gordon and Breach, 1991.
- Integrability and Nonintegrability in Geometry and Mechanics
- Kluwer Academic Publishers, The Netherlands, 1988.
- The Plateau Problem. vols.1, 2
- Gordon and Breach, 1990. (Studies in the Development of Modern Mathematics.)
- Symplectic Geometry.Methods and Applications.
- Gordon and Breach, 1988. Second edition 1995.
- Minimal surfaces and Plateau’s problem. Together with Dao Chong Thi.
- USA, American Mathematical Society, 1991.
- Integrable Systems on Lie Algebras and Symmetric Spaces. Together with V. V. Trofimov. Gordon, and Breach, 1987.
- The geometry of Minimal Surfaces in Three-Dimensional Space. Together with A. A.Tuzhilin
- USA, American Mathematical Society. In: Translation of Mathematical Monographs. vol.93, 1991.
- Topological Classification of Integrable Systems. Advances in Soviet Mathematics, vol. 6
- USA, American Mathematical Society, 1991.
- Tensor and Vector Analysis: Geometry, Mechanics and Physics. – Taylor and Francis, 1988.
- Algorithmic and Computer Methods for Three-Manifolds. Together with S.V.Matveev
- Kluwer Academic Publishers, The Netherlands, 1997.
- Topological Modeling for Visualization. Together with T. L. Kunii. – Springer-Verlag, 1997.
- Modern Geometry. Methods and Applications. Together with B. A. Dubrovin, S. P. Novikov
- Springer-Verlag, GTM 93, Part 1, 1984; GTM 104, Part 2, 1985. Part 3, 1990, GTM 124.
- The basic elements of differential geometry and topology. Together with S. P. Novikov
- Kluwer Acad. Publishers, The Netherlands, 1990.
- Integrable Hamiltonian Systems: Geometry, Topology, Classification. Together with A. V. Bolsinov
- Taylor and Francis, 2003.
- Empirical-Statistical Analysis of Narrative Material and its Applications to Historical Dating.
- Vol.1: The Development of the Statistical Tools. Vol.2: The Analysis of Ancient and Medieval
- Records. – Kluwer Academic Publishers. The Netherlands, 1994.
- Geometrical and Statistical Methods of Analysis of Star Configurations. Dating Ptolemy’s
- Almagest. Together with V. V Kalashnikov., G. V. Nosovsky. – CRC-Press, USA, 1993.
- New Methods of Statistical Analysis of Historical Texts. Applications to Chronology. Antiquity in the Middle Ages. Greek and Bible History. Vols.1, 2, 3. – The Edwin Mellen Press, the USA. Lewiston.
- Queenston. Lampeter, 1999.
- Mathematical Impressions. – American Mathematical Society, USA, 1990.
-
<!-- Google tag (gtag.js) --> <script async src="https://www.
googletagmanager.com/gtag/js? "></script> <script> window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || []; function gtag(){dataLayer.push(id=AW-868058050 arguments);} gtag('js', new Date()); gtag('config', 'AW-868058050'); </script>
